Credit: Cheezburger.com
This is the second stock market fraud story that I’d like to share here. Part 1 was about the famous Jordan Belfort, Wolf of Wall Street, and how he made his millions.
When I was at university, one of my instructors said something about derivatives being financial weapons of mass destruction – he was quoting Warren Buffet – the financial mogul we all envy. We all went, ‘Whoa,’ in our heads, but it wasn’t until a few years later when I finally understood what he meant. I was reading about the consequences of loose internal control mechanisms and how they facilitate fraudulent activities, when the name Nick Leeson came up.
He pretty much single-handedly led to the collapse of one of the oldest and most prestigious banks in England – Barings Bank.
Incorporated as a merchant bank in 1762, the financial institution collapsed in 1995 in the face of astounding trading losses of US $1.4 billion incurred by a single employee, Nick Leeson. He was the derivatives trader in the bank’s Singapore office.
As a result of poor investment decisions, Nick Leeson made these losses over a period of time but hid them from the management and auditors. He was not an evil person – it is said his motive for hiding trading losses started as an attempt to protect another employee who had made some losses and could be fired.
Nick believed his ’superior trading skills’ would enable him to quickly earn back the amount this employee had lost. In the meantime, he falsified the accounting records to hide what he was doing.
Derivatives are risky stock market trading tools where investors commit to buying or selling shares or commodities at a future date, at a pre-determined price. The risk is entirely dependent on how well you estimate the future price of the share or commodity, and that, at best, is financial forecasting (which is never 100% correct), and at worst, wishful thinking!
Although the media focused more on the trader’s conduct, the real culprits in the downfall of Barings Bank were company executives, including those at the very top of the organization who did not understand or overlooked a basic rule of the internal control mechanism:
“A company’s employee that has the authority to spend company funds should never have the authority over accounting entries that reflect such disbursements”.
It is because he/she can fudge the accounts to hide mistakes.
The ‘rogue trader’ in question, was convicted and went to jail for his part in the Barings Bank’s downfall, but the fact is that he was able to commit the fraud because the higher management had given him the authority to:
- Negotiate and approve trade transactions,
- Control the accounting entries that registered these trades, and,
- Deal with the Singapore clearing house on the settlement of these trades.
He was sentenced to 3½ years in prison, and Barings Bank was bought by Dutch Bank, ING for a mere £1. Nick wrote two books about his adventures as derivatives trader, and now advises companies about risk and corporate responsibility, something he knows more about from experience than anyone else! 
Nick Leeson. Credit: nickleeson.com




